moments before the wind.

May 16, 2006

be my head and i’ll be yours

Filed under: authenticity, business, distribution, music, news, reviews, rock, writing — alimarcus @ 7:13 pm

Jason Gross runs through the rockist/poptimist debate on his PopMatters blog. While I am trying very hard to stay out of this debate, he brings up some peripheral points about music writers that I think need some picking apart.

We scribes are the ones who sweat over this and debate it endlessly but many of our readers and the many more people who never read us could care less. It’s not just that they don’t know the terminology, it’s also that, frankly, this just doesn’t matter to them…But again, in the end, we writers live under the semi-delusion that our words will convert the masses or least help the converted entrench what they already believe.

Pretty depressing thoughts. It's just a "semi-delusion," so the glass is half-full, right? The downside to a little us-and-them argument is the revelation of a kind of unbridgable isolation, but the upside is the privilege of disseminating value, the concept of being a teacher and a catalyst. The "them" that refers to those-who-dont-read-music-criticism are still absorbing pop culture, they are still watching TV, they are most certainly on the internet, and probably rifling through Rolling Stone every now and then. Blogs, even these kinds of "flame war" arguments, generate hype, and guess what? People always respond to hype. Always. Information circulates so freely now that yes, it definitely takes a kind of talent to filter out the stuff that matters – but who would I be to criticize discussion? Is there anything worse than ignorance? Items become newsworthy (in print) when enough people fuss about them to warrant reporting. Blogs are just another way of fussing.

We should realize where these discussions really circulate and ultimately then, what they’ll mean for those involved. We’d like to think that we write for people who “get it” and it’s too bad if they can’t dig our debates. Then again, it’s too bad that we don’t think about how we do or don’t connect with a larger readership because of that.

Gross discredits the format of blogs as too informal to be justifiably credible. He is right that writers have to think more proactively about the things that are usually editor's jobs: readership, motivations, messages, etc. Or, maybe Web 2.0 will turn out to be an infant state for whatever comes next, something Pitchfork-esque that is structured similarly to print sources.

This is my favorite line, because I am frequently stating that most music is bad: "As with any genre, some of it will be great…and some of it will suck. "



  1. Well, one good turn deserves another! Thank you for the thoughtful comments.

    Just to clarify, I wasn’t trying to knock blogs in my other posting. I do two of them and when I see blogs like yours, I’m encouraged that this medium can be a potentially vibrant online salon. What I was trying to dispell was the notion that in ALL media (be it print or online) these overly esoteric conversations that we have about music and specialized terms to describe it is necessarily meant for a wider audience beyond ourselves. It often isn’t and I think it’s a problem that we fail to realize this or acknowledge it. If we’re trying to have a small conversation among ourselves which alientates the public at large, we’ve done a great job of it. If we really do care about reaching the hearts and minds of people outside of regular circle with our ideas, we need to think more about the work that we’re doing.

    As for the influence of blogs, the discussions that bubble up from there aren’t ones like these but instead they’re things like political scandals and record recommendations.

    Comment by Jason Gross — May 17, 2006 @ 8:44 am

  2. Apparently this one has bubbled.

    Comment by alimarcus — May 18, 2006 @ 7:12 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: